Thursday, March 25, 2010

Influential books game

NYT columnist Ross Douthat outlines this exercise pretty well. I enjoyed writing this but am now tired, so I'll leave you with his explanation:

More than a week ago, Tyler Cowen kicked off an irresistible blogospheric listing exercise: In this case, the theme is “10 books which have influenced your view of the world.” You can find Matthew Yglesias’s list here, Will Wilkinson’s list here, and many more at this link. My own follows below. Note that these are not my 10 favorite books, nor the 10 best books I’ve ever read, but the books that quickly came to mind — I was following Cowen’s “go with your gut” admonition — as having shaped my writing or pushed me in one intellectual direction or another over the years. As an experiment, I’ve also tried listing them in rough chronological order, starting with the books that influenced me as a child and working my way upward (or downward, perhaps) toward adulthood. And like many people, I’ve cheated and gone over 10 — in my case, by doubling up on a few that share an author or a theme.


1. The Giving Tree, by Shel Silverstein
I recently picked this childhood favorite up again, reading it to a class of first graders at an independent school in Washington, D.C. as part of a job interview. I led a short discussion about the book and its themes after reading it aloud, and that reminded me why I loved the book so much growing up. I was initially drawn to it because my older cousin really liked it, but after reading through it on my own (probably one of the first books I ever read, in fact), I was struck immensely by the simplicity and beauty of the parable and its themes. It's a story of self-sacrifice, altruism, and a powerful relationship that was out of balance; The Giving Tree was my first exposure to these ideas, many of which stuck with me through the years.

2. The Client, by John Grisham
The Grisham series of legal thrillers served as my introduction into "adult" literature. I remember picking this one up during a summer where I was too adult to be content at my grandmother's house, but not yet old enough to stay home alone. I became immersed in Grisham's suspenseful prose, and this book, along with other well-known novels like The Pelican Brief and A Time to Kill, helped enhance my nascent love of reading.

3. The Diary of Anne Frank and Anne Frank: The Biography, by Melissa Muller
I read the biography first, which led me into the diary itself, and the story told pairwise in such a way was immensely powerful. The story is I think universally known, but it was important to me because I picked the biography up just a few years after my father died--I think it was in 7th grade, or not quite 5 years later. Without realizing it, I had been shortchanged of half my identity in a way, cut off from the part of myself that is Jewish by my father's passing. These readings started me on a path of self-discovery which eventually brought me to Israel. Though I'm far from converting formally to Judaism, the Anne Frank story inspired me to learn more and embrace that part of my background, even though it wasn't always easy.

4. Animal Farm and 1984, by George Orwell
This was another book read during a lazy summer at my grandmother's house in Long Island, also suggested by a cousin, if memory serves. After reading through once and missing many of the subtleties (remember, this was many years ago), I started again at the beginning. This time, the metaphors and allegories jumped off the pages, and the seeds of a political malcontent had been planted. When I read 1984 during freshman year, I remember being fascinated by the dystopic view Orwell so vividly outlines. I also caught so many parallels from Animal Farm that my understanding was really improved.

5. Catch-22, by Joseph Heller
This was also read during my 9th grade year, and it was the first great war novel I ever encountered. In addition to opening this genre up to me and training me to hate war from an early age, I learned an early lesson about existentialism and nihilism. Yossarian's prime goal was to "stay alive or die trying," which in a war zone might be a pretty fair life goal. This view emphasized the questionable value of staying alive, a crazy idea which led me to explore ideas like structural violence and warm peace later in life.

6. Lies and the Lying Liars who Tell Them, by (now Senator) Al Franken
When a comedy writer for Saturday Night Live came out with a political book...well, I don't remember why I saw the need to read this, but I'm so glad I did. It actually served as my introduction to blogosphere, netroots politics, because so much of Franken's political writing belongs on a blog, with links and source material. He actually composed a carefully reasoned, well-researched dismissal of Faux News, and his argument helped sway me farther to the left of U.S. politics.

7. A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius, by Dave Eggers
I don't remember when I first picked this book up, I just remember it as the only book I've ever read 4 times, cover to cover. Changed my life so much.

8. Racism Without Racists, by Eduardo Bonilla-Silva
One or two academic books have to appear on this list. This one actually was assigned in probably my least favorite class at Tufts, but it was so educative that I won't hold the class against the book, which I enjoyed even at the time. Bonilla-Silva opened a world of blind, unspoken prejudice to me which I wasn't aware of, and through the course and this text in particular, I learned about structural inequality and the racism (and accompanying privilege) that exists beyond consciousness.

9. Stranger in a Strange Land, by Robert Heinlein
Take one part dystopia in the style of Orwell or Huxley, mix well with social commentary unparalleled in anything I've read, and finish with the style of Douglas Adams and you've got Heinlein in a nutshell. It was the discussion of the human experience that caught my interest, and I took one quote out in particular which I still remember:
"I've found out why people laugh," the Martian immigrant explained. "They laugh because it hurts...because it's the only thing that'll make it stop hurting." He follows this thread on the next page: "I had thought--I had been told--that a 'funny' thing is a thing of goodness. It isn't. Not ever is it funny to the person it happens to...The goodness is in the laughing. I grok [understand] it as a bravery...and a sharing...against pain and sorrow and defeat."


10. Death at an Early Age and Shame of the Nation, by Jonathan Kozol
This is why I want to work in education. Kozol's dramatic writings, first as a new teacher in Boston Public Schools and later as an experienced critic, opened my eyes beyond the inequality I saw growing up. He convinced me that education reform really is the civil rights struggle of my generation.

No comments:

Post a Comment